Curbed
The Best of the New New York Architecture
Two other supertalls, both by SHoP, puncture the atmosphere without disdaining the block. Both 111 West 57th Street, the world’s skinniest skyscraper, and 9 DeKalb Avenue, a.k.a. Brooklyn Tower, grow out of the early-20th-century landmarks at their feet, projecting their deluxe graciousness into the sky.
Warren & Wetmore’s 1925 Steinway Hall presides over 57th Street, a limestone memory of classical music’s glory days, and SHoP’s vertical addition draws out its poise, its rhythm, and its showy ease. Up at the top, the crown falls away, feathering to nothing, like a long pianissimo trill, a feat of attention-getting lightness. This is a huge accomplishment, offering a way out of the battle between contextualism and contrast.